Skip to Content
/Recipes/Desserts/Banoffee Pie Recipe

Banoffee Pie Recipe

Banoffee Pie Recipe

June 26, 2011 /
Categories Desserts, Cakes, Novice, Recipes

banoffee pie

Surprise, something new is on Craft Passion!!!! This time, it is not a craft pattern neither nor a tutorial… it is a real dessert that I made on Father’s Day. This is the first-ever recipe in Craft Passion and the first-ever banoffee pie I’ve attempted. If you like to see more recipes in Craft Passion, please give me a shout yay!!!

Banoffee pie is the first authentic English dessert I have ever tasted, I love it!!! I confessed that I have a serious sweet tooth, I gawk to the dessert aisle before deciding if I am going to dine in for the buffet cuisine. Unfortunately, since the last bite 17 years ago, when I was studying in England for my Master’s Degree at the University of Warwick, I haven’t got a chance to eat banoffee pie anymore… I really miss it!!! I can’t find any place in my country that sells authentic banoffee pie, not even in the popular English tea house, so I have to make one myself.

After research through the net to recall the way my hall-mate made it, I was confident to try my luck for the first time. Hey, it is so easy and simple, I have made a success in my first attempt, not bad!!! And, this banoffee pie is for my husband’s father’s day celebration, he doesn’t like sweet thing… BUT, he likes this banoffee pie I made which I have adjusted the sweetness!!!

Make a pot of Earl Grey Tea and have a piece of banoffee pie on a lazy afternoon….. a perfect English tea!!!!

Banoffee Pie Recipe


Banoffee Pie

Another name: Banana Toffee Pie

Serves: 8
Prepare time: 30 minutes to 1 hour for the pie, 2-3 hours for the toffee.
Pie Base
Digestive biscuit (use McVities if possible) – 300 gram / 10.5 oz
Butter (melt)- 200 gram / 7 oz
Fillings & Toppings
Banana ~ 3-4 medium size
Sweetened Condensed Milk – 1 can (~500g, can make 2 portions)
Whip Cream
Dark Chocolate
Cinnamon Powder / Cocoa Powder
Utensils & Tools:
9.5″ Tart Pan with removable bottom
Silicon Scraper
Big Pot
Rolling Pin
Zipper bag (Large)
Kitchen Weighing Scale

banoffee pie method

  • Place the unopened condensed milk in a big pot, fill with water to cover the whole can. Boil for 2 -3 hours. Make sure the condensed milk is fully immersed in the water all the time. Wait till it is cool before opening the can. While waiting for boiling and cool down, prepare the biscuit crumb pie base.
  • Put digestive biscuits into a large zipper bag, release extra air & close the zip. Crush the biscuits with the rolling pin till fine.[1]
  • Pour crushed biscuits and melted butter into a big bowl, mix well with a fork.[2]
  • Spread the mixture on the tart pan, press on the base and side of the pan. Put into the fridge to chill while waiting for the toffee to ready.
  • Open the condensed milk when it is ready and cool to touch. The toffee is thick and in brown color.[3]
  • Slice the bananas.
  • Spread the toffee and bananas on the biscuit crumb pie base.[4]
  • Put back into the fridge until it is ready to be served. Spread the whipped cream on top, sprinkle some chocolate gratings, dust over some cinnamon powder or cocoa powder. Served chilled.

Serving Suggestion:
Eat the filling with the biscuits crumb base together. The filling is sweet and the biscuit base is a little salty, feel the tranquility when they melt and mix in your mouth.


  • You can prepare the toffee 1 day beforehand to shorten the preparation time so that you don’t have to wait for it to boil and cool down while making the pie.
  • Since my husband doesn’t like a sweet dessert, I adjusted the recipe to reduce the toffee and increase the biscuit crumbs. If you like it sweet, add more toffee to your banoffee pie.

Screen Shot 2017 05 30 at 9.53.47 AM


Subscribe via email for latest updates:


Giveaway Winner: June 2011
← Read Last Post
Basic Kid Shorts With Pocket Pattern
Read Next Post →