Banoffee Pie Recipe

Today I share with you not a craft pattern, nor is it a tutorial on sewing. It is my debut post in my recipe section! As my first ever recipe on Craft Passion, I decided to share this banoffee pie recipe I attempted this Father’s Day. It was definitely a risky attempt as the chocolate shavings and sweetened condensed milk make this popular English dessert one suitable for those with a sweet tooth and my husband is definitely sweet averse. However, what fun is baking without a challenge?

When my skeptical husband took his first bite into this baked banoffee pie, he shut his eyes as he savored the delicious banofee pie and gave his hum of approval. The melted butter holds the fine crumbs of the digestive biscuits perfectly as a pie crust, and it balances the sweetness of the sliced bananas and toffee bits wonderfully. Hence, I present to you this easy banoffee pie recipe that will hopefully make its way into the hearts of your anti-dessert friends and family alike!

Origins of the Banoffee Pie Recipe

I had my first taste of this classic British dessert 17 years ago when I was studying in England for my Master’s Degree at the University of Warwick.

My thoughtful hallmate, knowing that I have a serious sweet tooth, baked me this banoffee pie as a housewarming gift to welcome me to England. Ever since then, I have searched high and low in Malaysia for a café or patisserie that sells banoffee pie, but to no avail. Not even in some of the most popular English tea houses here, so I had no choice but to put on my baking apron and give this banoffee pie a go in order to taste the delicious pie once again. I succeeded in my first attempt, this is how easy this recipe is!

Banoffee pie is a traditional English dessert invented by Nigel Mackenzie and Ian Dowding in East Sussex, England. The funny thing was, the reason that they invented this dessert was that they wanted to amend what they deemed an unreliable American recipe for “Blum’s Coffee Toffee Pie” from Blum’s Bakery in San Francisco in 1917. The original American cake did not include any fruits, but Mackenzie and Dowding decided to elevate the recipe by first testing with apple and mandarin orange. However, they ultimately settled with the banana and toffee combination.

Well, regardless of the reasons they decided to do it, we have them to thank for this amazing match made in heaven which is bananas and toffee.

What are your favorite food combinations?

Is it banana and toffee? Chocolate and peanut butter?

Let me know in the comment section down below!

Banoffee?

The unique name is derived from the medley of ingredients used to make this scrumptious British pie which are bananas + toffee hence banoffee!

Banoffee pie is traditionally made from bananas, cream, and a thick caramel sauce (made from boiled condensed milk or a can of dulce de leche) with fresh bananas, combined and spread in an even layer on a buttery graham cracker crust base or one made from crushed biscuits and melted butter. Other variations of this recipe include dark chocolate, coffee, or both, and the top of the pie is often lathered with homemade whipped cream and sprinkled with cinnamon powder or cocoa powder.

BANOFFEE PIE RECIPE

scroll ⬇️ to get the detailed and printable recipe

The Banoffee Experience

This delicious yet simple banoffee pie recipe contains four layers:

1. A delicious digestive biscuit crust (you can replace it with a graham cracker mixture of graham crackers as well).
2. A smooth, caramel toffee made by heating sweetened condensed milk in low heat or medium heat till it boils (homemade dulce de leche).
3. Slice bananas on top of the toffee filling.
4. And on top of the bananas, we have freshly whipped cream.

If it is the first time you trying this banoffee pie, you will indubitably be blown away by the explosion of flavors and textures that you will experience in just one bite. The best way to eat this in a serving plate is to eat the filling with the cookie crust together.

The filling is sweet from the thick dulce de leche and banana slices and the crunchy graham cracker crust is a little salty, truly the perfect combination. All this is balanced out by the light and airy soft peaks of the freshly whipped cream, and then you get a dash of sweetness again from the chocolate shavings. I am instantly transported back to England with every bite. Serve chilled with a cup of Earl Grey tea, and there you have it — an authentic English tea experience.

Adjustments for sweet tooths and non-sweet tooths

When I was preparing this banoffee pie, I made some adjustments to the original recipe, reduced the toffee, and increased the biscuit crumbs (I used McVities), as my husband is not a huge fan of all things sweet. For those of you who have a major sweet tooth, you can always increase the toffee filling or sliced bananas. If the toffee filling still isn’t sweet enough for you, you can always mix brown sugar or confectioners’ sugar into the filling in a medium bowl over low heat.

If you have tried this banoffee pie recipe and loved it, I have more recipes in my recipe section for you to master, and if you would love to give more sweet desserts a go, I have a cake recipe section that will definitely catch your fancy. Some cake recipes worth highlighting are my noteworthy cheesecake recipes. You can always try my Japanese Cheesecake, Blueberry Cheesecake, Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake, and Matcha Cheesecake, and for those who want to indulge without guilt — Low Carb Cheesecake and Burnt Cheesecake both are flourless keto desserts perfect for those who are in a keto or low-carb diet.